Discussions

BryceBruins · BRHL2 Co-Commish

RE: Discussions

Wolves GM · Senior Member

Can we claim a player and put them back into waivers unprotected within the same turn with means to demote them to the farm?

BryceBruins · BRHL2 Co-Commish

same turn, no. claim in one round, drop in the next, sure

Wolves GM · Senior Member

How could James Sheppard be selected in the waiver draft?
He was injured for all of last season and therefore shouldn't even be available for play. Don't players need at least 10 games played to receive ratings? Shouldn't Sheppard be listed within his team's prospects section instead?

HOTLANTA · Guru

nope i guess they all get ratings.. thats what issue was with LA and his goalies.. he figured that Harding would be moved to prospect list seeing as he didnt play last year. but instead had to expose brent johnson

Hummers · Veteran Member

Wolves GM wrote:
How could James Sheppard be selected in the waiver draft?
He was injured for all of last season and therefore shouldn't even be available for play. Don't players need at least 10 games played to receive ratings? Shouldn't Sheppard be listed within his team's prospects section instead?

Not if it's injury related.. always been that way in the BRHL at least.

HOTLANTA · Guru

it used to be the rule in brhl2 aswell. Erik Johnson was on prospect list for a year in our league with that knee injury he had.. i guess the rule has changed..

-- Edited by HOTLANTA on Monday 7th of November 2011 04:09:05 PM

-- Edited by HOTLANTA on Monday 7th of November 2011 04:09:57 PM

BryceBruins · BRHL2 Co-Commish

We detailed early in the offseason guys with injuries were getting ratings just discounted. Gives us a uniform policy across the board, and allows us to track contracts easier. Guys had ratings, no reason to think they shouldnt have to be protected etc.

Predsgm · Guru

sorry. i knew my pick would cause controvery but the updates the commishes sends they try and clarify everything they can. besides im taking a gamble on sheppard. he looks like a bust in the nhl.

Wolves GM · Senior Member

BryceBruins wrote:
We detailed early in the offseason guys with injuries were getting ratings just discounted. Gives us a uniform policy across the board, and allows us to track contracts easier. Guys had ratings, no reason to think they shouldnt have to be protected etc.

Fair enough. Cheers!

BryceBruins · BRHL2 Co-Commish

And ya, Sheppard sucked before he was hurt, why woudl he be better now LOL

Capitals GM · Senior Member

BryceBruins wrote:
And ya, Sheppard sucked before he was hurt, why woudl he be better now LOL

Because he doesn't play for a ****ty Minnesota team.

HOTLANTA · Guru

BryceBruins wrote:
We detailed early in the offseason guys with injuries were getting ratings just discounted. Gives us a uniform policy across the board, and allows us to track contracts easier. Guys had ratings, no reason to think they shouldnt have to be protected etc.

curious what the situation would be with a guy like Kurt Sauer off the caps shouldnt he have some rates.. (would help washington meet roster requirements some)

Wolves GM · Senior Member

HOTLANTA wrote:
BryceBruins wrote:
We detailed early in the offseason guys with injuries were getting ratings just discounted. Gives us a uniform policy across the board, and allows us to track contracts easier. Guys had ratings, no reason to think they shouldnt have to be protected etc.
curious what the situation would be with a guy like Kurt Sauer off the caps shouldnt he have some rates.. (would help washington meet roster requirements some)

1 game played in the 2009-2010 season and nothing since... [cough]

Is that the best you've got? It's obvious that Sauer was removed from BRHL's ratings prior to last offseason. Hence the reason he's still unavailable.

I truly hope you didn't have to research that example to hard, Kirk becuase it's a terrible arguement.

HOTLANTA · Guru

my question is that he is out because of injury like sheppard whose last games were also the 09-10 season.. so shouldnt sauer have some kinda rating?