Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
BRHL Home -> BRHL2 Message Board -> Main Board -> LA TYLER---- ME ATL--- Debated and then decide to list please join in
Post Info TOPIC: LA TYLER---- ME ATL--- Debated and then decide to list please join in
HOTLANTA


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 2233
Date:
LA TYLER---- ME ATL--- Debated and then decide to list please join in
Permalink  


So we decided out of boredom and love for the league to spend a about an hr thinking about it and rank our top 30 assets BRHL2. their was one done of 5-10 early in offseason before alot of g.ms got here.  were hoping this one could envoke some good discussion during the offseason now with the board pretty crazily active from a good chunk of the g.m's..

so top 30 brhl2 Assets in a complete dispersal draft who would be ur first round list..


MINE KIRK ATLANTA

#1)   Ovechkin-obviously
#2)   Crosby- obviously
#3)   Price- With his dead low salary 78 rate with great attributes he is in my top 3 over malkin whose russian flight risk skills scares me.. he might legein hockey imo.. if Price turns into another brodeur great 10+ yrs of 85+goalie is unreal or heck turco good his 10+ yrs of 80+ goaltending puts him here for me..

#4)   Malkin- dont need to say anything will be #3 on almost everyother list/
#5)   Kovalchuk- 5.5 million 4 yrs then rfa deal.. most dominate offensive guy for sim this yr not named AO. will continue to pop 50 a yr nhl aswell.
#6)   Heatley- 50goal-50assists for two straight nhl yrs,, 3.5 mill only for this yr with very high rates. still young and paired with another guy on this list in nhl doesnt hurt. Heatleys is the total package as NHL player.

#7)   Luongo- Best goalie assets for team looking 3 yr window.. his salary will be tough to swallow for a career- 8+ per yr is the rumours...
#8)   Zetterberg- insane rates with nice contract to bad its only for 1 yr before a big payday.... perfect all-around player sim and NHL..
#9)   Phanuef- Physical force in sim that will be scary.. Age/potential have him ranked 9th.
#10)  Vinny-Proven Champ. Proven brhl2 champ twice lol. total package though as a player which is rare for a french player..
 #11)  J.Iginla- Purest form of a powerforward the NHL has this guy is a freak with his combination of strength and speed the two things the every coach dreams about.. ohh and also is one of best captains in nhl..
#12)  R.Nash- could u even leagally drink to celebrate ur rocket richaurd trophy year when u won it rick?? this guy is going to be Iginla Jr. reason he is behind iginla even tho younger is because he hasnt just made that step i think the difference 11th and 12th on in my list is big.
#13)  M.Richards- Total package doesnt have the pure offense to make my top 10 but he is still damn good and like i said a complete package in bobby clarke mold hmm howd he get that??
#14)   Kopitar- Freakishly good but still somewhat unknown but is a complete package muxch like a E.Staal, but younger cheaper.
#15)  H.Lundqvist- 3 time vezina finalist, is going to be a 6-8 yr fhl starter for whoever gets him at around 7 mill averaged out..
#16)  P.Kane- Filthy young hockey player, has vision and the pure skill to think and play a couple seconds ahead of everyone thats why his size is zero issue. crosby is strong kid. Kane has zero strength but doesnt need it except to develop more snipe which will come leaving ur teaanage years..
#17)  J.Thornton- Best PP player in NHL imo with only four guys on ice and it taking TWO take take joe off the puck its pretty easy formula for whoever he plays for..
#18)  E. Johnsson- Rob Blake cloned.. but with newer feet. a lil quicker than blake even in his prime IMO.
#19)  R.Getzlaf- is a horse. ok he floats some but still, he has size/speed/shot combination that is rare.
#20) M.Gaborik- Speed and snipe off the wing to dazzle anyone. his huge payday hurts his value on my list a little but pure skill hed be top 10..
#21)  P.Stasny- Heir to Joe Sakic's throne.
#22)  J.Toews-  very good two-way player in mold of old mike modano just not as fast..more of a leader though forsure...
#23)  C.Pronger- CP44 has to make the list he is a freak in sim and real life which wont change some guys on this list their is risk involved his guarenteed excellence puts him in 23 on my list.
#24)  E.Staal- Great offensive player always seems to find the loose puck around nets, or in corner to feed open teammates. High high hockey IQ from so many games having to beat his brothers 3-1 or maybe hed take jared in his diapers hahaha..
#25)   J.Spezza- to much a floater to be any higher. but his skill is undeniable.
#26)   J.Bouwmeester- Stallion of a d-man asked to be anchor of everything on a sinking sinking ship in nhl. in brhl2 he is in heaven passing to crosby-iginla-zets-kopita on the PP..
#27)   N.Backstrom (wsh)- gets to play with that #1 guy and is pretty filthy himself.
#28)   A.Hemsky- Freak of nature offensively with puck, got paid a rumoured 90% of the raise shawn horcoff got from oilers management.
#29)   Z.Chara- Physically dominate beast in the FHL world. salary isnt to overcostly which is also a bonus.
#30)  S.Gagner- filthy vision, if speed and snipe come will move into everyone top 15...


spent about 30-40 min putting this together so not to bad..

lets hear it about my list at least...

__________________
BluesGM


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 991
Date:
Permalink  

if you had the 3rd overall pick, everyone after you would feel great, price shouldn't be taken until 20-25

__________________
Hawks_G


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 861
Date:
Permalink  

I agree with Gareth. If I pick fourth, I jump for joy. Everyone else on the list seems good...although I would probably move Kane down a bit....and Hemsky up. I think his upside will show this year and he will be in the top 25 in NHL scoring.

__________________

xtremehockey.wordpress.com
Rumpy


Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 308
Date:
Permalink  

Let me say Kirk set this up poorly this arguement all came about from this interesting but terrible list tsn did.   http://www.tsn.ca/columnists/scott_cullen/?id=247112&lid=headline&lpos=topStory_nhl

I think my list is far superior to Kirk's and since I'm a loser and I'm bored I did top 50 like TSN.


1 - Crosby
2 - Ovechkin
3 - Malkin
4 - Loungo
5 - Thornton
6 - Lecalvier
7 - Iginla
8 - Nabakov
9 - Lidstrom
10 - Brodeur
11 - Heatley
12 - Getzlaf
13 - Kovalchuk
14 - Zetterberg
15 - Staal
16 - Gaborik
17 - Chara
18 - Lundqvist
19 - Nash
20 - Datsyuk
21 - Phanuef
22 - Kopitar
23 - Richards
24 - Spezza
25 - MA Fleury
26 - Boumeester
27 - Stasny
28 - Toews
29 - Green
30 - Backstom
31 - Weber
32 - Price
33 - Kane
34 - Turris
35 - DiPetro
36 - Seabrooke
37 - Gagner
38 - Hemsky
39 - Miller
40 - E.Johnson
41 - Hossa
42 - Turco
43 - Pronger
44 - Gagne
45 - Kiprussof
46 - Bergeron 
47 - Carter 
48 - Morrow
49 - Camalleri
50 - Savard
 
Can't really go wrong with these guys some notibles left off the list the Sedin's Perry Gomez Marleau St.Louis Briere and I'm sure there are many more.

I might go through later and see what BRHL team has the most guys off my top 50.  I'd guess Atl Chi SJ and Buf have a lot right now. 

After looking at Kirk's list that isn't much better than TSN's I noticed I missed E.Staal already so I'd put him around the 20 - 25 range.

-- Edited by Rumpy at 11:45, 2008-08-21

-- Edited by Rumpy at 13:29, 2008-08-21

__________________
philly


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 1184
Date:
Permalink  

yeah way to pimp your assets kirk... price over luongo hey... is that before or after carboneau pulls him for halak???


also I would like to add for nomination to somewhere in the 25-40 OV assets, even though some will disagree...


Mikko Koivu.
Look at his NHL totals:
Regular Season Playoffs
Season Team Lge GP G A Pts PIM GP G A Pts PIM
2005-06 Minnesota Wild NHL 64 6 15 21 40 -- -- -- -- --
2006-07 Minnesota Wild NHL 82 20 34 54 58 5 1 0 1 4
2007-08 Minnesota Wild NHL 57 11 31 42 42 6 4 1 5 4

This season he will be playing top-line with Gaborik. Will be playing top-line PK. Contract is 900k for this season in our league, and a very modest 3.25 mil for next 3 seasons in NHL. meaning I will able to get this guy locked up long-term on the VERY cheap.

Also here is a list for you, tell me what they have in common: Heatley, Doan, Kovalchuk, Datsyuk, Crosby, Kopitar, Zetterberg, Iginla, Spezza, Thornton, Lecalvier, B. Richards, Malkin, St. Louis, Horcoff, Alfredsson, Savard, BrindAmour, Hossa, Roy, Ovechkin, Staal, M. Richards, Stastny, M. Koivu

If you guessed they are all forwards that is correct. If you guessed they are all 80+ OV you would be wrong - Savard and Koivu don't make the cut. The secret that Im trying to get across: all of these guys have EN ratings of 77+. Which means there is a very strong correlation to ice time in NHL equalling better rates in BRHL2. The point I am trying to make is that if the coach in the NHL trusts you a lot and puts you out in every situation, its likely that you are one of the best players.

That is why im projecting Koivu to be an 80+ player next year, barring injury. And at a cost of less than 3 million, he will shoot up the list.


OK, now have at telling me how wrong I am. smile

__________________
Get ahold of me soon, or my players will already be dealt!
HOTLANTA


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 2233
Date:
Permalink  

start youe own thread rexxxxxx this for lists


__________________
HOTLANTA


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 2233
Date:
Permalink  

ps loungo 8.7 is hurtung next yr hey rex

__________________
BluesGM


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 991
Date:
Permalink  

1 - Crosby (Buf)
2 - Ovechkin (SJ)
3 - Malkin (Col)
4 - Loungo (Phi)
5 - Thornton (Chi)
6 - Lecalvier (Chi)
7 - Iginla (Buf)
8 - Nabakov (STL)
9 - Lidstrom (SJ)
10 - Brodeur (Buf)
11 - Heatley (Atl)
12 - Getzlaf (Bos)
13 - Kovalchuk (Atl)
14 - Zetterberg (Buf)
15 - Heatley (Atl)
16 - Gaborik (Chi)
17 - Chara (Atl)
18 - Lundqvist (NJ)
19 - Nash (Tor)
20 - Datsyuk (Bos)
21 - Phanuef (Bos)
22 - Kopitar (Buf)
23 - Richards (Tor)
24 - Spezza (Car)
25 - MA Fleury (Det)
26 - Boumeester (Buf)
27 - Stasny (Was)
28 - Toews (Buf)
29 - Green (Chi)
30 - Backstom (Was)
31 - Weber (Buf)
32 - Price (Atl)
33 - Kane (Det)
34 - Turris (Was)
35 - DiPetro (LA)
36 - Seabrooke (SJ)
37 - Gagner (Bos)
38 - Hemsky (Atl)
39 - Miller (Bos)
40 - E.Johnson (Buf)
41 - Hossa (Mtl)
42 - Turco (SJ)
43 - Pronger (Det)
44 - Gagne (Dal)
45 - Kiprussof (NYR)
46 - Bergeron (Was)
47 - Carter (Buf)
48 - Morrow (Col)
49 - Camalleri (Det)
50 - Savard (Edm)

According to your list, Buffalo has 10, Chicago 4, SJ 4 and Atlanta has 6....


__________________
HOTLANTA


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 2233
Date:
Permalink  

he has heatley twice.. thats why i have 5 guys i see.. the picks of ufas seem off to me i dunno id never go ufa in top 2 rounds of a league draft.. and rex koivu would be looking more round 4 than mid 2nd IMO...

__________________
philly


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 1184
Date:
Permalink  

that is definitely your opinion... but you also have price ahead of malkin... enough said..

__________________
Get ahold of me soon, or my players will already be dealt!
HOTLANTA


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 2233
Date:
Permalink  

lets see a list rex

__________________
Anaheim GM


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 781
Date:
Permalink  

Maybe it's time to find another adjective...  biggrin

HOTLANTA wrote:

#16)  P.Kane- Filthy young hockey player, has vision and the pure skill to think and play a couple seconds ahead of everyone thats why his size is zero issue. crosby is strong kid. Kane has zero strength but doesnt need it except to develop more snipe which will come leaving ur teaanage years..
PP..
#27)   N.Backstrom (wsh)- gets to play with that #1 guy and is pretty filthy himself.
#30)  S.Gagner- filthy vision, if speed and snipe come will move into everyone top 15...



__________________

2007-08 - missed playoffs (29th overall)
2008-09 - missed playoffs (26th overall)
2009-10 - 7th place in Western Conference (99 pts), Conference Semi-Finals
2010-11 - missed playoffs (19th overall)
2011-12 
BluesGM


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 991
Date:
Permalink  

my guess is he'll use dirty :P

__________________
Sabres_Luke


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 1009
Date:
Permalink  

Rumpy wrote:

1 - Crosby
2 - Ovechkin
3 - Malkin
4 - Loungo
5 - Thornton
6 - Lecalvier
7 - Iginla
8 - Nabakov
9 - Lidstrom
10 - Brodeur
11 - Heatley
12 - Getzlaf
13 - Kovalchuk
14 - Zetterberg
15 - Staal
16 - Gaborik
17 - Chara
18 - Lundqvist
19 - Nash
20 - Datsyuk
21 - Phanuef
22 - Kopitar
23 - Richards
24 - Spezza
25 - MA Fleury
26 - Boumeester
27 - Stasny
28 - Toews
29 - Green
30 - Backstom
31 - Weber
32 - Price
33 - Kane
34 - Turris
35 - DiPetro
36 - Seabrooke
37 - Gagner
38 - Hemsky
39 - Miller
40 - E.Johnson
41 - Hossa
42 - Turco
43 - Pronger
44 - Gagne
45 - Kiprussof
46 - Bergeron
47 - Carter
48 - Morrow
49 - Camalleri
50 - Savard



#47 may be dealt tonight along with Kris Letang. Get your offers in ASAP. Be real though because the top one is good.

 



__________________
"With Sid on your team, anything is possible" - Mario lemieux
BryceBruins


BRHL2 Co-Commish

Status: Offline
Posts: 2320
Date:
Permalink  

According to TSN, I have 3 of the top 9 guys Getzlaf #4, Datsyuk #5, and Phaneuf #9.

Bruins RULE!!!

__________________

bryceshuck@brhlhockey.com


     BRHL             BRHL2           BRHLE              BRHLJ
0_nhl_hockey_minnesota_wild.gif    boston-bruins-playoff-tickets.png   LogoRussiaDynamoMoscow.jpg   Edmonton.jpg
1 2  >  Last»  | Page of 2  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.
BRHL Home -> BRHL2 Message Board -> Main Board -> LA TYLER---- ME ATL--- Debated and then decide to list please join in
Tweet this page Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us


Create your own FREE Forum
Report Abuse 		Powered by ActiveBoard