Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
BRHL Home -> BRHL2 Message Board -> Main Board -> Ratings
Post Info TOPIC: Ratings
Sabres_Luke


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 1009
Date:
Ratings
Permalink  

Just wondering, but has BRHL every considered a revised rating methodology? Its a bit strange to me that Roberto Luongo could be at and .883 save % after 25 games. I think the difference between a top goalie in this league and a average #1 isn't the same as a top goalie is in the NHL- hence tim thomas last year, and even this year in the sim. Also Marty played more mins than any goalie last year (I believe, may not luongo) and this year i can't play him 2 games in a row unless I want him to be at a 99 or 98 health, and he's on pace for the most mins this year. Something's not right.

Another one for skaters is the fact that players on horrible teams get better ratings mainly because no one else is there to play minutes. How duvie westcott (who was sent down this year on CLB) ever got the same rating as Weber and Suter is beyond. I know we've gone over this before, and it's not complaining at all, I just want to see if anyone feels the same way. Maybe its unavoidable but just wanted to see what people thought.

__________________
"With Sid on your team, anything is possible" - Mario lemieux
Hawks_G


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 861
Date:
Permalink  

I have talked to Bryce about BRHL ratings for a few years now.

My thoughts have always been that there should be more dispairity between elite players and not so elite players.

I have also thought that the DF formula relying on PK stats to determine DF leaves some important stuff out.  A great example is using a kid like Cogliano on your PK.  He isn't on the PK because he is good defensively per se, but faster than lightning.  His DF is going to reflect that.

I haven't seen the formula for ratings, but it would be cool to see.  As for the Duvie Wescotts of the world, that would be tougher, because you have to measure him against his peers, and that has to be quantifyable.

__________________

xtremehockey.wordpress.com
Philippe27


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 920
Date:
Permalink  

I spent about 5 hours talking to Eric in the off-season begging him to change them and a good amount of time talking to Bryce a few weeks ago and he said player ratings aren't changing, goalie ratings might be reviewed a little but not as much as any of us would like.
It's unfortunate because in my mind this is the only obvious aspect of this league that's lacking. Bryce's knows where I stand but I don't think he agrees with any of us however and I think we just have to respect that.

-- Edited by Philippe27 at 17:32, 2007-12-18

__________________
Moncton GM


Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 21
Date:
Permalink  

Only reason I joined this league was because of the ratings. Dont change them Eric.

__________________
capsgm


Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 376
Date:
Permalink  

Vancouver wrote:

Only reason I joined this league was because of the ratings. Dont change them Eric.



 ahem...biggrin



__________________
Moncton GM


Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 21
Date:
Permalink  

capsgm wrote:

 

Vancouver wrote:

Only reason I joined this league was because of the ratings. Dont change them Eric.



ahem...biggrin

 



Gesundheit



__________________
NYRGM


Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 328
Date:
Permalink  

I love the ratings as well and was also a big reason why I opted for this league in the beginning having known what the ratings system would be like.  I do however feel that some ratings should be reviewed when those strange cases are brought forward.  Thanks-Joe  NYRGM



__________________
Ianintheam


Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 458
Date:
Permalink  

I think, as a whole, the BRHL ratings are some of the best out there.

__________________
"Theres also talk of creating more room at the end of the rink by making the nets more shallow, which would be accomplished by encouraging them to spend all their time listening to pop music and reading Twilight books."

Email: ianintheam@yahoo.com
ICQ: 302759748
Page 1 of 1  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.
BRHL Home -> BRHL2 Message Board -> Main Board -> Ratings
Tweet this page Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us


Create your own FREE Forum
Report Abuse 		Powered by ActiveBoard