Opinions on Trades- Preseason 2007

nuckfan · Veteran Member

RE: Opinions on Trades- Preseason 2007

Sabres_Luke · Guru

nuckfan wrote:

Sabres_Luke wrote:

TO NYR: RYAN POTULNY
               ANDREW HUTCHINSON
               NIKLAS BERGFORS
TO BUF: NOAH WELCH
               NYR 1ST 09
               NYR 2ND 09
               1 MILLION CASH

Is that a real trade or just an example? I don't think 2009 picks are available to be traded (or at least I hope not) unless that team has paid for 2 years of BRHL2 hockey.

He has.

Sabres · Guru

Its a real trade, he paid for 2 years down the road.

Sabres · Guru

Is everyone just retarded or are you trying to be difficult?

Post the trades in the same format as the sample at the start of the official trades thread. No one wants to read a novel about your friggen basic trade. This thread is suppose to be easy to read and in chronological order.

If you want to post a "story" about your trade, do it on the main board.

I cant believe how much people need to be babysat to initiate something like this.

LAKings · Senior Member

Sabres wrote:

Is everyone just retarded or are you trying to be difficult?

Post the trades in the same format as the sample at the start of the official trades thread. No one wants to read a novel about your friggen basic trade. This thread is suppose to be easy to read and in chronological order.

If you want to post a "story" about your trade, do it on the main board.

I cant believe how much people need to be babysat to initiate something like this.

That doesn't sound like an opinion on a trade.. maybe you should be posting that elsewhere.

Sabres · Guru

Is that Roszival trade going to get accepted?

Philippe27 · Guru

to atlanta zdeno chara, brad boyes, alexander semin, st.louis 1st
to st.louis- alex frolov, ryan malone, adam foote, rusty klesla, iyla bryzgalov, atl 3rd

Is this serious?
Semin<>Frolov and Malone
Boyes<>Foote (because Foote is overpaid and old)
Klesla and Bryzgalov for Chara and STL1?

If people thought my deal with St.Louis should have been vetoed what do they think about this one?

Sorry if I sound bitter but some of these deals are retarded.

Sabres_Luke · Guru

Philippe27 wrote:

to atlanta zdeno chara, brad boyes, alexander semin, st.louis 1st
to st.louis- alex frolov, ryan malone, adam foote, rusty klesla, iyla bryzgalov, atl 3rd

Is this serious?
Semin<>Frolov and Malone
Boyes<>Foote (because Foote is overpaid and old)
Klesla and Bryzgalov for Chara and STL1?

If people thought my deal with St.Louis should have been vetoed what do they think about this one?

Pretty much how I saw it as well.

Islanders GM · Senior Member

Philippe27 wrote:

to atlanta zdeno chara, brad boyes, alexander semin, st.louis 1st
to st.louis- alex frolov, ryan malone, adam foote, rusty klesla, iyla bryzgalov, atl 3rd

Frolov is coveted in many fantasy leagues and is arguably almost equal to Chara
(especially with age and contract differences: Chara worth 6 mill for FOUR years? mayyyybe)....

Bryzgalov and the 3rd is arguably equal to the 1st rounder......

that leaves Malone (74 ov), Foote (76 ov), Klesla (75 ov) for Boyes (71 ov), Semin (77 ov).

not so lopsided.... a 60/40 kind of deal by some considerations (though arguably 70/30)

philly · Guru

agreed... i see it this way:

frolov-semin (90% close in ATL favour)

bryzzy-stl 1st (100%)

malone-boyes (90% close in ST.L favour)

foote, klesla, 3rd-chara (80% close in ATL favour)

SOUR GRAPES IN TB AFTER THEY MISS OUT ON ANOTHER DEAL!!!!!!!!!

-- Edited by BryceBruins at 12:43, 2007-08-09

Sabres · Guru

STL got raped. I dont know how the frig you can say STL wins on the Boyes for Malone deal. Malone is a piece of trash compared to Boyes.

-- Edited by Sabres at 11:49, 2007-08-09

BryceBruins · BRHL2 Co-Commish

am I the only one who likes Frolov more than Semin??
Why is everyone so high on Boyes? How many chances is he going to have to prove himself?

philly · Guru

i like frolov more than semin as well, but since semin has that entry level contract he is more valuable to a roster close to the cap (atl)......

and malone is better than boyes IMO, and based on opportunity/exposure playing on a sid the kid team, he is a better asset....

the rest is fairly close, so TB needs a reality check.

Sabres_Luke · Guru

philly wrote:

i like frolov more than semin as well, but since semin has that entry level contract he is more valuable to a roster close to the cap (atl)......

I'm not arguing for the sake of arguing, I like frolov more too, but Semin's value is substantially greater. 3 years at 850k compared to frolov who will get quite an increase. Not to mention, Semin is younger, and in his 1st full NHL season he put up more than Frolov ever has.

Sabres · Guru

I think Semin is a flash in the pan... Frolov is very comparable to him IMO. Too bad Chara, one of the top 3 dmen in the league was also dealt in this deal....