Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
BRHL Home -> BRHL2 Message Board -> Main Board -> Ratings test with new scale as I suggested
Post Info TOPIC: Ratings test with new scale as I suggested
Philippe27


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 920
Date:
Ratings test with new scale as I suggested
Permalink  

Ok so basically I took the current BRHL ratings and for IT, SP, ST, SK, PA, PC, DF and SC I expanded the scale (multiplied each rating by 1.55 and subtracted 42) so that the ratings went more or less from 95 to 35.
I also expanded it for goalies in a similar way, here are the scoring leaders from my test season:
Player GP G A P +/- PIM PP SH Shots Sh%
D.ALFREDSSON(NJ) 82 61 57 118 46 44 16 1 276 22.1
J.THORNTON(Chi) 82 40 74 114 27 136 7 0 268 14.9
I.KOVALCHUK(Edm) 82 54 55 109 47 98 9 3 320 16.9
J.CHEECHOO(Phi) 82 65 40 105 57 65 12 0 264 24.6
S.GAGNE(Clb) 82 63 42 105 49 67 17 1 307 20.5
A.OVECHKIN(SJ) 82 50 53 103 24 58 9 2 286 17.5
P.MARLEAU(Tor) 82 39 64 103 11 42 4 2 300 13.0
P.ELIAS(Mon) 82 31 72 103 42 52 5 0 263 11.8
B.RICHARDS(Col) 82 44 56 100 21 73 5 0 273 16.1
J.IGINLA(Mon) 82 53 46 99 44 98 13 0 268 19.8
E.STAAL(SJ) 82 51 48 99 26 75 11 4 258 19.8
P.DATSYUK(Bos) 82 36 62 98 39 42 8 0 223 16.1
J.ARNOTT(Edm) 82 41 56 97 32 150 6 4 244 16.8
P.FORSBERG(NJ) 82 32 64 96 57 75 4 1 222 14.4
D.HEATLEY(Atl) 82 43 51 94 13 107 16 4 269 16.0
B.ROLSTON(Dal) 82 39 55 94 18 87 4 2 272 14.3
M.HOSSA(Bos) 82 43 50 93 40 93 6 0 312 13.8
B.GIONTA(Clb) 82 42 51 93 54 33 13 0 212 19.8
E.COLE(Dal) 82 37 56 93 22 69 7 4 260 14.2
S.GOMEZ(Ott) 82 37 55 92 33 69 11 0 232 15.9
Y.PERREAULT(Pho) 82 47 43 90 34 57 12 1 237 19.8
M.MODANO(Clb) 82 21 69 90 48 82 4 2 224 9.4
O.JOKINEN(Was) 82 44 44 88 4 86 17 2 310 14.2
C.CONROY(NJ) 82 35 53 88 24 129 11 1 256 13.7
J.SPEZZA(Car) 82 26 62 88 18 88 4 1 195 13.3
C.STILLMAN(Pho) 82 26 62 88 26 57 5 0 235 11.1
J.STOLL(Phi) 82 22 66 88 50 74 5 2 163 13.5
C.ARMSTRONG(Phi) 82 29 58 87 26 106 9 2 185 15.7
M.SAVARD(Edm) 82 33 53 86 28 82 6 4 243 13.6
R.NASH(Tor) 82 51 34 85 15 59 12 0 259 19.7

Player GP W L T MIN GA SO AVG PIM Shots Pct A
M.KIPRUSOFF (NJ ) 61 44 20 4 3603 119 11 1.98 0 1533 .922 1
T.VOKOUN (Clb) 71 46 17 10 4118 137 7 2.00 14 1770 .923 4
R.LUONGO (Phi) 69 46 23 7 4024 139 3 2.07 0 1814 .923 1
M.BRODEUR (Pho) 67 49 16 6 3914 142 7 2.18 0 1715 .917 1
M.LEGACE (Dal) 69 42 23 5 3884 143 6 2.21 0 1804 .921 0
R.MILLER (Ott) 65 39 21 8 3783 149 10 2.36 2 1643 .909 2
M.TURCO (TB ) 72 42 24 6 4172 165 5 2.37 17 1786 .908 1
D.HASEK (Edm) 65 45 22 3 3854 155 9 2.41 13 1740 .911 1
C.HUET (Chi) 74 41 30 4 4268 182 5 2.56 0 1993 .909 1
J.GIGUERE (Ana) 67 35 30 6 3911 168 6 2.58 4 1868 .910 3

I barely spent any time on this so there are guys with 60-65 goals which we don't want too many of.
What you can see from this is there are still many overachievers and many underachievers but overall
it is a lot more realiistic than what we have currently, especially for goalies.

Thoughts? Suggestions? Step in the right direction or not?



__________________
PHO


Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 128
Date:
Permalink  

definitely a step in the right direction....i agree, too many 60/65 goal scorers isnt too good
nick



__________________
99, 66, 8 : Sundin-less Coyotes
OilersBrent


Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 263
Date:
Permalink  

As a Leaf fan, not too pleased with who led the league in scoring....

__________________
Philippe27


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 920
Date:
Permalink  

PHO wrote:

definitely a step in the right direction....i agree, too many 60/65 goal scorers isnt too good
nick


Yeah I used a 95-35 scale and there's tweaking to do of course to fix the stats and make them accurate, say make it 88-35 for SC and keep the others were they are or something, not too hard to adjust in an hour or two.

 



__________________
Habs


Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 117
Date:
Permalink  

Did you sim using the current BRHL2 rosters or did you use the reall NHL rosters?

__________________
Philippe27


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 920
Date:
Permalink  

Habs wrote:

Did you sim using the current BRHL2 rosters or did you use the reall NHL rosters?
Current BRHL2 rosters (you can see the team name in paranthesis), as you can see Alfredsson is leading the league but playing with Forsberg is makes sense, Elias and Iginla up there playing together etc.

 



__________________
Habs


Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 117
Date:
Permalink  

I'll leave my opinion on what I think should be done out of this, casue I'll live with what we do. Either way and there are pros and cons to both. However, it would be nice to see Iginla get 53 goals compared to 28.

__________________
Sabres


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 1215
Date:
Permalink  

Freakin brilliant..Like you said to many top scorers..but easily could iron things out and run even up to 4 or 5 more tests.

__________________
Philippe27


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 920
Date:
Permalink  

Just to add, notice Crosby is not in the leaders, he actually had 80 pts and he was playing with Dustin Brown and Jeff Carter. Even top players are not guaranteed to be in the top if they play with 3rd-4th line players and there will still be random overperformers like Yanic Perreault with 90 pts and there will always be but way fewer than currently.

__________________
Habs


Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 117
Date:
Permalink  

Just wondering if there is anyway we could see the all the players stats? I just thought it would be interesting to see what some of the other players ended up with

__________________
San Jose


Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 226
Date:
Permalink  

Habs wrote:

Just wondering if there is anyway we could see the all the players stats? I just thought it would be interesting to see what some of the other players ended up with
Ya, Id like to see that also,

anyway u can upload the HTML output on a page we can all accees?

The SIM is all about probability...and a team with better players should have better probability of winning.....i am for the new rating system



-- Edited by San Jose at 23:08, 2007-03-21

-- Edited by San Jose at 23:08, 2007-03-21

__________________
Jackets1


Veteran Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 55
Date:
Permalink  

Looks good to me

__________________
macchia


Veteran Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 36
Date:
Permalink  

yaaaap

__________________
YAP
Philippe27


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 920
Date:
Permalink  

Here's a link to the Team Scoring and League Leaders:
http://www.freewebtown.com/philippe27/BRHL2TeamScoring.html
http://www.freewebtown.com/philippe27/BRHL2Leaders.html

It took me about 10 minutes to adjust the ratings so with a little more work they can be greatly improved, this just gives you an idea of the results.

__________________
Jackets1


Veteran Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 55
Date:
Permalink  

Philippe27 wrote:

Here's a link to the Team Scoring and League Leaders:
http://www.freewebtown.com/philippe27/BRHL2TeamScoring.html
http://www.freewebtown.com/philippe27/BRHL2Leaders.html

It took me about 10 minutes to adjust the ratings so with a little more work they can be greatly improved, this just gives you an idea of the results.
Those are genius, 100% better than what we've got now!



__________________
1 2  >  Last»  | Page of 2  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.
BRHL Home -> BRHL2 Message Board -> Main Board -> Ratings test with new scale as I suggested
Tweet this page Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us


Create your own FREE Forum
Report Abuse 		Powered by ActiveBoard